I found the best smartwatch for kids, and it's not an Apple Watch or Garmin

Google recently launched the new Fitbit Ace LTE, a kids’ smartwatch that gamifies physical activity to encourage movement in exchange for playtime on the device. The coolest thing about it is that Google doesn’t skimp on the features; it’s a great smartwatch on its own, so you can presumably trust it to only get better in time, as evidenced by some recent updates.

Also: Skip the iPad: This $190 tablet is redefining what a kids tablet can do

The new Fitbit Ace LTE features a large 41mm by 45mm Gorilla Glass watch face, which seems huge for a kids’ smartwatch but proves to be just the right size in practice. All the games are meant to be played on the watch, so the extra screen real estate is readily appreciated when kids are interacting with it. 

For comparison, I’ve tested the Xplora XGO3 for over a year. This $130 kids’ smartwatch requires a monthly data subscription and gamifies physical activity. However, the Xplora XGO3 gives kids virtual coins in exchange for steps taken, which they can exchange for games on a phone or tablet. It’s also very limited in what kids can write — there’s no keyboard in the messaging app — and it has fewer features than the Fitbit Ace LTE. 

Also: I tested the Samsung Galaxy Ring and it’s smarter than my Apple Watch in one big way

Using the Fitbit Ace LTE

This smartwatch is so feature-rich that I decided to break down the biggest ones based on my kid’s experience using each one:

‘Noodles’ or activity rings

The Fitbit Ace LTE features a pedometer and heart rate sensor to track steps taken, light physical activity, and active exercise. Kids wearing the smartwatch start each day with a Move Goal displayed on their screen as a Noodle, similar to an Apple Watch’s Activity Rings or Wear OS fitness tracker. 

Also: This sleep-tracking baby sock was one of the best purchases I made as a new parent

Like most features on the Fitbit Ace LTE, Noodles are customizable. Kids can choose their preferred Noodle and see an animation when it transforms to an upgraded version after they complete their daily move goal. For example, it can be a cartoon snake getting closer to a leaf bug as the day progresses. When the Move Goal is reached, the snake eats the bug and changes color as it ‘dies,’ seemingly poisoned.

Google added new Noodles for kids to choose from in November.

Fitbit Arcade games

Games on the Fitbit Ace LTE are unlocked as the kid wearing it reaches exercise goals, with new features available as the kid moves more. The watch features games played through physical activity, like fishing and golf, which require arm movements. My kid particularly loved the fishing game Smokey Lake, which has new locations where she can try catching different fish. However, these locations are an X number of steps away, unlockable only if she completes the set number of steps. 

The Fitbit Ace LTE only works with the Fitbit Ace Pass, so you can’t bypass the subscription to use the smartwatch. The Fitbit Ace Pass, paid monthly or annually, gives the wearable access to calls, messaging, GPS location, and games. The games are part of Fitbit Arcade, accessible only with the data plan and updated almost daily. These games don’t have in-game purchases or need to be downloaded; they only become available when the child does physical activity.

Google launched the Fitbit Ace LTE with six games and promised that new games would soon be available in the Fitbit Arcade. Subsequently, the company added two new games for Fitbit Ace users, including Sproutlings and Spirit Garden. Now, Google announced it’s adding Solar Sword, a new game, to the Fitbit Arcade.

‘Eejies’ or avatars

Each watch has an Eejie, an avatar that kids can customize and keep happy by achieving move goals. Eejies live in a house in Bit Valley that kids can decorate, unlocking rooms as they progress to different levels. Think of an Eejie as a modern-day Tamagotchi (without the hatching or dying). 

Also: How we test smartwatches at ZDNET in 2024

If parents allow it on the Fitbit Ace app, kids can friend each other in Bit Valley when two or more Fitbit Ace LTE users are nearby. Their Eejies can interact in Bit Valley but can’t message or call each other. When added as siblings with Fitbit Ace devices, kids can communicate with each other on the smartwatches. 

Also: One of the longest-lasting sports watches I’ve tested is also the most gorgeous

Bit Valley has occasional ‘Snowstorms,’ which occur when a kid has spent too much time in the virtual world. These snowstorms encourage kids to do something else besides decorating their house in Bit Valley, like get moving.

Interchangeable wristbands

Google sells different wristbands in polyester yarn and sports finishes. But unlike other smartwatches, each band unlocks a new Noodle, levels up their Eejie’s house, and has new decor and outfits for their Eejie. The bands each have a theme, like the Strange Arcade, Moovin, Spooky Pugs, Glitterbomb Skate, Camp Nightmare, and Courtside. The different wristbands only add to the watch experience, so kids don’t lose their Eejie or any progress they made before switching bands.

Fitbit Ace app for grownups

The Fitbit Ace LTE looks more like a grownup smartwatch than one for kids, but it doesn’t include a phone number with the Ace Pass. Instead, the watch requires the parents and anyone who will communicate with them to use the Fitbit Ace app on their iOS or Android smartphone, which gives them full access to their kids’ smartwatch settings, location, data plan, messaging, calling, and more. 

Also: The best tablets for kids: Expert tested and parent recommended

The Fitbit Ace app lets parents see their kids’ recent activity broken down into “light” and “active” categories and steps taken. There’s no way to track sleep, which is one feature I’d like to see. The app also doesn’t show heart rate data, even though it monitors it to track movement and discern from light and active exercise. I don’t mind the lack of heart rate data during the day, as it varies by age, which could lead to false alerts, but I’d like to see it incorporated with sleep tracking.

Kids can’t message anyone they want because the watch has no phone number attached to the data plan. Only approved users with the Fitbit Ace app can message the kid wearing the Fitbit Ace LTE smartwatch. Google just announced family chats, which lets parents create groups and send messages to everyone in them. 

Also: The best sleep trackers of 2024: Expert tested and reviewed

Parents can also add emergency contacts that can be reached via phone when the watch is set to school mode, a way to avoid distractions during a predetermined time. The app allows breaks in school time to give kids access to the smartwatch’s features during lunch or recess.

The Fitbit Ace LTE lets kids call and send text and voice messages, but parents can’t send voice messages, which is a minor inconvenience I’d love to see corrected. The messages also don’t support large stickers or photos, so you can’t send your kid a cute photo of their pet or a funny sticker. While kids and approved contacts can send emojis, they look tiny in the mobile app and on the watch. 

Also: The best GPS trackers for kids in 2024: Expert recommended

Google added Google Wallet with tap-to-pay to the Fitbit Ace LTE, which works with a debit card from Greenlight or GoHenry and will help teach kids responsible money skills. When kids make a transaction, parents will receive an alert on the Fitbit Ace app. I’ve tried it a few times by putting my daughter’s birthday gift card money in her GoHenry account so she can check out herself at stores.

ZDNET’s buying advice

I’m not ready to get my second-grader a phone. I know she’ll forget it somewhere, or one of us will forget to charge it, rendering it useless. The Fitbit Ace LTE is the perfect device for giving kids control over their day, connecting them to approved contacts, and tracking their location when needed. 

This summer, the smartwatch gave me some actionable insight into my kid’s activity level. When she went to day camp, her daily physical activity doubled and sometimes tripled that of the days she stayed home. As her parent, this motivated me to get them all moving more during the summer when it’s easy to fall into a routine of screens and snacks.

Also: The best smartwatches of 2024: Expert tested and reviewed

After testing it for the past few months, I found that the Fitbit Ace LTE is the only kids’ smartwatch I would wholeheartedly recommend to parents with kids between the ages of 6 and 14 who can read and navigate a touchscreen. It’s a simple platform, futureproofed by Google in a way that justifies its price and succeeds in getting kids moving. I’m even planning on buying a second one for my second kid when she learns to read.

The Fitbit Ace LTE does have a few areas it could improve, but they can be remedied with future software updates, and ultimately, the pros outweigh the cons.